In search for the true Tragopogon porrifolius
Tragopogon is a rather critical genus as far as its taxonomy is concerned.
Here in the Mediterranean there are at least two other species resembling T. porrifolius L., T. eriospermus Ten. and T. cupanii Guss. ex DC., the latter endemics to some southern Italian regions.
For a rather long time T. porrifolius and T. eriospermus have been confused. Instead, despite both having "purple" flowers and inflated scape below the capitula, the two species are rather easily distinguished:
-
T. porrifolius: 1) ligules maroon , very short, less than 1/2 of phyllaries; 2) phyllaries slightly reflexed at flowering; 3) achene body slightly narrowed into rostrum; 4) leaves strongly undulate at margins; 5) growing in dry habitats:
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/115326371 -
T. eriospermus: 1) ligules violet, longer than 1/2 of phyllaries and up to as long as phyllaries; 2) phyllaries porrect at flowering; 3) achene body strongly narrowed in a very narrow rostrum; 4) leaves not undulate at margins; 5) growing in wet habitats:
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/115324011
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/100764720
Here the original description of T. eriospermus and the first drawing:
http://www.ortobotanico.unina.it/FN/TV/TV0176.PDF
http://www.ortobotanico.unina.it/FN/TavoleFN/t0186.PDF
The type of T. porrifolius has been selected here:
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1222832
and can be viewed here:
https://linnean-online.org/9553/
Most of the observations of T. porrifolius from North America refer to another taxon that is more similar to T. eriospermus:
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations?place_id=97394&taxon_id=54141
In Europe it is just slightly better...
Maybe could it be worth revising the presence of the "purple-flowered" Tragopogon in North America?
To do this, apart photographing the capitulum and the scape below the capitulum, it would be useful to photograph:
1) leaves: undulate/not undulate at margins
2) phyllaries: reflexed/porrect at flowering
3) achenes when dried: achene body strongly narrowed into a very narrow rostrum or just slightly narrowed
4) habitat: dry or rather wet