Comparing Scapania Species in Coastal PNW

Scapania is like the Sphagnum or liverworts--instantly recognizable to genus but then agonizing to go beyond that point. The unequally bilobed leaves with their ovate-reniform lobes are an instantly recognizable feature. There are about a dozen species in coastal BC, many clustered in subalpine habitats. I will try to add more to this table as I am able to dig up records. Using a combination of habitat and leaf features, it is possible to get to species. It turns out the shape, relative size and attachment of the characteristically unequal leaf lobes is the key to figuring this genus out. Three words from this table should be off-putting so I will explain them up front: Dorsal lobe refers to the overlapping part of the lateral leaf that you see on top when you look down at Scapania from above. It is generally smaller than the underlying ventral lobe, which is most visible and prominent when looking at the underside of the shoots. Ventral leaf decurrency refers to the way the leaf is attached to the underside of the lobe. Instead of attaching transversely across the stem, a decurrent leaf runs down along the edge of the stem for a while. This great photo by Richard Droker shows the ventral side (on the left) next to the dorsal side (on the right) of Scapania bolanderi. You can see that the leaf margin begins to parallel and descend along the stem. It is "decurrent".

Each species below is linked to an iNaturalist observation that attempts to demonstrate the features in this table. If you want to get very deep in to Scapania, try the provisional Bryophyte Flora of North America Key to Scapania (link to pdf treatment of all species of family Scapaniaceae in North America north of Mexico).

Species Habitat Teeth Keel Dorsal Lobe: Ventral Lobe (length ratio) Lobe shape Ventral Leaf Decurrency Other features
S. bolanderi Trees, Logs, Stumps, DOM Coarse Straight ~.75 round-reniform Present Dominant species in low elevation coniferous forests
S. americana Rocks and Mineral Soil Coarse Straight ~.5 round-reniform Absent Frequently deep red
S. paludosa Subalpine meadows,  hygrophytic present or absent Arched ~.65 reniform Absent very short keel
S. undulata along drainage on soil, rocks and DOM present or absent Straight ~.75 round-reniform Absent Lobes tightly appressed, often purplish
S. umbrosa Logs (often on the wood) Coarse Straight ~.5 triangular-round Present very small plant, Pointed lobe apices
S. gymnostomophila Limestone near drainage absent Weakly arched ~.3 Ovate-oblong Present giant oil bodies 1/cell
S. uliginosa Subalpine meadows absent weakly arched ~.7 ear-shaped Present Plants "scorched", blackish
S.obscura Seeping subalpine/alpine humusy soil absent straight ~.75 Ovate-oblong Absent
S. subalpina Sand and rocks, predominantly subalpine minute straight ~.9 Ovate Present Lobes seemingly equal
S.scandica Sandy soil absent ? ~.75 triangular-ovate Present
S. mucronata Rock, Soil over rock absent ? ~.5 ovate Present
Posted on January 17, 2023 11:14 PM by rambryum rambryum

Comments

What is "DOM"?

Posted by stewartwechsler over 1 year ago

@stewartwechsler DOM= Decaying Organic Matter. Pardon me-- my own mental shorthand bleeds out.

Posted by rambryum over 1 year ago

Thanks! It's easy to slip into using our own shorthands without remembering that our audience might not know it!

Posted by stewartwechsler over 1 year ago

Wonderful post!

Posted by mattunitis over 1 year ago

Excellent work @rambryum ! —Thanks for this

Posted by chlorophilia over 1 year ago

thanks!

Posted by iancruickshank over 1 year ago

Another great post, thanks! Time to find some of these and fill in those question marks.

Posted by bradenjudson over 1 year ago

@bradenjudson the one to hunt down at this time of year (no access to the subalpine) is Scapania umbrosa. I don't see it often, but when i do it tends to be on fallen logs across creeks and seasonal drainage.

Posted by rambryum over 1 year ago

Thanks @rambyum, this is great!

Posted by johndreynolds over 1 year ago

link is broken to the Richard Droker photo?

Posted by doviende about 1 year ago

@doviende I have fixed it. Thanks for pointing out.

Posted by rambryum about 1 year ago

I recommend actually linking to the exact photo like this: https://www.inaturalist.org/photos/2655288
because currently it's linking to the taxon page, but that might change in future to feature a different photo.

Posted by doviende about 1 year ago

@doviende --fixed again

Posted by rambryum about 1 year ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments

Gracias al apoyo de:

¿Quiere apoyarnos? Pregúntenos cómo escribiendo a snib.guatemala@gmail.com